I have a 2023 catcher that will be 15 end of this Sept. Age wise, he should have been a 2024. We were not thinking about sports at all when we transitioned from from homeschooling to a school when he was 2nd grade. We asked his school to test him a year higher as we feel like he is emotionally, mentally and academically ready. So we went the opposite way of other parents asking school to keep their kids down a year.
Right now, he has a wonderful group of friends, fits in well (too well in my opinion), and has a 4.0 GPA. We have no regrets with the decision even thought he has kids 2 years older than him in his class (kids of parents who held their child back a year). My son also has no problems with this decision... until now.
My son effectively sat out sports for a year. He got injured on the base paths at the beginning of summer baseball last year that needed major surgery. He started training again in Dec and got in as the HS team's backup catcher to a senior committed to an SEC college. He learned a lot from this senior catcher but he didn't get to play in this covid shortened varsity season.
Fast forward to the start of summer travel ball. He had his first tournament this past weekend. I was surprised at this increase in velocity. He pitched 78 to 80 mph consistently, and had an in-game pop time of 2 seconds. He has never been to any showcases so I don't have his other metrics like exit velo or 60 speed, but he's one of the fastest in his team, and bats leadoff. He got invited to PG 14u nationals at Ft Myers happening end of July so we will know more where he stands by then.
The problem is in the midst of all these, kids he knows and plays with/against for years that are in the 2023 and 2024 class are now being recruited (or at least they claim in social media that they are) and are committing to P5 schools. Granted, these are the kids that have been showcasing a lot the past several years and have parents who have been aggressively marketing their kids (I haven't done any of that as I've always though, maybe naively, that my son's play will speak for itself).
Seeing kids around him now being recruited and committing while no one is even noticing him is starting to make my son frustrated. He is now complaining a lot to me why I didn't reclass him to 2024 last summer as a rising 9th grader. He said his numbers would have shined a lot more as a true 2024. I keep telling him to stay the course, that starting a year ahead in life gets him so much more benefits outside of baseball, and to use this as an encouragement to work and train harder. I tell him that these commitments mean nothing, that these kids still has to progress as expected, that he can take their spot once he starts showing recruiter what he can do. He keeps saying that 2023 classes in the good schools are all filled up by his Junior year and there will be no spot for him regardless of how good he is by then.
Honestly, I'm now questioning myself if putting him a year ahead academically was a mistake. But how was I to know back in 2nd grade that he will do good in baseball come HS time. So here're my questions in posting this (beyond just venting):
1. Reclassing is obviously not an option anymore. But is post grad (or gap year) an option? But how will that work if the really good P5 and SEC schools already have the recruiting classes filled up 2 or even 3 years before graduation? Will he really have to excel and be 2x better than someone who is already verbally committed for a college to be willing to drop that recruit for him?
2. Any stories or tips that I can give him right now from you all's experience to encourage him?
3. PG 14u Nationals will be his first ever showcase. My understanding is that this is a legit showcase (not just a money maker), right? Any tips for this showcase? Is there any value in getting him to a smaller (and cheaper) show case before that to get him more ready? I hate to spend more money unnecessarily unless there is real value to it.
Thanks for listening. Hopefully, I can look back 4 years from now at this post, and share with other parents going through the same thing how every thing worked out in the end...