My last post on this:
—Most of you are talking about the habits of the 1% of baseball players and generalizing from that. Most HS players will not play college ball. High standards are great, but most kids on a HS team are not the players people are talking about here
—Chico Jr’s goal is an HA school. He will pick a school for its academics first, because he ain’t going to earn his living in MLB and he knows it. To attend a 5 am workout at the expense of his Physics grade would be foolish. Maybe he could do pre-dawn workouts and still get the grades he wants, but if a conflict were to emerge, his parents are going to frog march him to the library, not the weight room.
—My son has offseason workouts 5 days/week, including 8 am on Saturday. Weekday sessions are after school plus one day at 8 pm. Based on the logic of some posters, he would be better off if instead he worked out at 5 am, because that would be harder and therefore make him more disciplined. Heck, why stop there?—he could wake up at 3:00 a.m. to work out and then grab another hour of sleep at 6:00. That would be harder, so therefore better, right? My position is that HS kids are better off if they don’t have to be in the gym at 5 in the morning on school days. That is not a bold claim, guys. Telling me your kid did it and was ok doesn’t mean it’s a good idea for an entire HS program if there is an alternative. Biology is what it is—most teens don’t function optimally on that early a schedule
—My son is responsible for his own calendar. As a junior, he is better at this than he was as a sophomore. When he goes to college in ~2 years, I expect him to be more mature and responsible than he is now. If his college coach schedules 5:00 am workouts, then my son will have to deal with that. This doesn’t change my position that most 16- and 17- year olds are likely to perform better in high school if they don’t begin their day puking in the gym before dawn.
Chico, I seem to have angered you with my post. That was not my intent. However, I won't apologize for taking these kids and giving them the opportunity to improve themselves. Again, no one was ever forced to come, roll was not taken, and I was doing what I thought was right. I always say that some people look for excuses to lose and I give reasons to be win. While it doesn't matter, my daughter grew up doing these workouts as well. She went on to become an NCAA All American and a Scholastic All American. So, I didn't ask something of someone else's child that I didn't ask of mine. Again, she was never forced to go.
Isn't it funny how people interpret a given event? I looked at what we did as doing more than my job. I looked at it like I was giving these players a chance to become the best that they could be. You look at it like I did something wrong. You think it harsh or even cruel. I came from a school that contended for state titles every year and were nationally ranked each year to a program that no one knew. I came from a program where players went to major D-Is and were drafted to a school that hadn't had someone play major D-I and had one play professionally in the 1940s. I wanted to give my new players the same effort I gave to my previous players. Give that opportunity in two sports. Chico, when I hear about how hard people work to coach a team, I wonder if they know how to build a program. It starts at the top. It starts with high expectations. I was told I had a year to win our I would be fired. It was very controversial when I made the switch in schools. I came to a "Coaching Graveyard." The basketball team won 3 games or less for 10 straight years. The baseball team, while respectable had never won a regional. The school I came from once beat this school 29 - 0.
Well, I'm rambling. Many here followed the success of my teams back in the day. We started winning and winning a bunch. We started winning regional titles and beating some of the best teams in the state. For a school of 1000, we were regularly beating schools of 2,400+. We had players drafted, playing in the B1G, ... The basketball team also began to win the conference, regional championships and sectional championships. In fact, they were listed in Streets and Smith as one of the Top 100 up and coming basketball programs in America.
In the end, parents agreed with Chico's position that I demanded too much in basketball. I resigned after winning 24 games, 2 tournaments and losing in the sectional championship. In a couple of years, the basketball team didn't win a game. They are on pace this year to win five or less. If it is any consolation, neither the baseball nor the basketball team do what I did back then so, you won't have to worry. Coaches like me don't last long now. This is my last year and yes, the softball team gets after it. We might be a contender this year for a state title. Then, they too can worry about other things than the old man.
Edited to add:
I forgot to address the notion that I do things after school. I don't know about your schools but boy's basketball has 3 teams and girl's basketball has 2 teams. The wrestling team has 2 teams. In our school, track gets a balcony and they do pole vaulting up there. Cheer-leading and Drill Team get the small gym when the basketball teams aren't in there. Also, indoor track gets any other open time. Finally, we have intramural sports and they get any other gym time in the evening when either gym is open. We had as an option 6 a.m. or nothing. Since I was coaching basketball and had to scout, 6 a.m. was my only option regardless of anything else.