To close, let's reiterate the key phrase, EVERYTHING BEING EQUAL. Of course there are plenty of great players who are not big guys. That said, there is a reason two major league MVP's, Jimmy Rollins and Dustin Pedroia ( I had the good fortune of coaching both) were both 2nd round picks instead of 1st round picks. They are 5'8 on a good day and history shows that bigger guys are a safer bet. It works THAT way!
quote:Originally posted by LHPMom2012:
I understand why. I'm just not sure I believe the conventional wisdom behind it. The implication is that height is a causative factor for baseball ability, or atleast a correlating factor. So in other words, we could line up all MLB players, tallest to shortest, and find a correlating decrease in batting average and increase in errors. For pitchers, the taller they are, the smaller their ERA. But I don't think it works that way.
LHPMom