Some background first...my oldest son is 17 and a senior in HS that had a great junior year as a starting pitcher. He kept his team in the game in every start going at least 5 innings for a competitive AAAA HS team in GA in a tough baseball region.
Our school has had at least 5 seniors every year sign on to the next level with a few of them drafted in June draft for MLB the last several years. We are accustomed to radar guns in the stands. As a junior he threw 85-87 consistently with a great curve and a solid change-up and spotted his pitches good enough to never have to 'give in' to hitters.
He has a great academic record ranked 23rd in a class of 450 with a 95 average through high school. He has taken honors and AP classes, and has taken SAT once with a math and verbal score of 1100. He is taking the test again next month to try and improve that score even though it meets requirements for all schools interested in him.
After some tweaks in his mechanics this summer, he has suddenly experienced an increase in velocity lately where he has bumped 90 on many occasions on the stalker gun for college coaches watching him pitch a bullpen for recruiting purposes. His fastball has been consistently at 87-89 in his games this fall in front of college recruiters. He is 6'0", 185lbs built on chicken fingers and pizza with a lot of growing to do. He has never taken a vitamin or protein shake in his life and has a lot of potential to grow and develop. He has fielded calls from a dozen schools interested in him begging him to come and make a campus visit.
This is where it gets interesting. Most of the schools are reputable JUCO programs. His first official offer came from a NAIA specialty private school with sparkling academic and athletic credentials. They claim 86% of graduates in his degree get jobs within 6 months of graduation and they have been very competitive on the field with 3 RHP getting drafted in the last 4 years under the current pitching coach.
They offered full tuition on athletic grant in aid ($30,000/year) but he is responsible for books, room and board which could put him $11K per year in student loan debt for a 5 year Masters degree in Architecture, of which the school has offered to pay 5 years of tuition toward the degree which he seeks even though he is only athletically eligible for 4 years.
The head coach has indicated to me he will start as a freshman because he "could use him this year" (his senior year of HS) since they don't make that kind of financial committment to a player they plan to develop for a couple of years before he can make an impact. They are a 4 year school that doesn't recruit from JUCO schools because so little credits transfers to their specialty degrees.
The downside is, he is concerned about incurring student loan debt when some of these JUCO'S are offering full ride with some money in his pocket due to his academics and HOPE and Pell grants. Thing is, monetarily, they will pale in comparison to the best offer already received. These other schools typically cost about $6500- $10K/year to attend and HOPE (lottery funded grants for students with B average)can cover about $4K of that without playing baseball.
Since I am not in a economic position to put my kid through college, how do I convince him it is worth going in debt ($50K) over a 5 year Masters degree toward an eventual $100K job vs. a Community College that has no guarantee to a 4 year institution of playing baseball just because they can put some eat/gas money in his pocket for 2 years? Draft considerations notwithstanding, how would you counsel your son comparing a total education worth about $205K with $150K covered in scholarship and grants vs. the JUCO route attaining a $20K associates degree paid for by someone else?
Original Post