Skip to main content

2021 got vaccinated. We waited months to “let them play”—don’t want a bad illness or the excuse of “contact tracing” to derail the short high school season for 14 days. Same thought for collegiate league that is only weeks long. Oh, and we were at the Angels game Saturday night that got canceled thanks to Twins contact tracing   >

No politics—just want our son to get to play baseball again!

College already require lots of extra vaccinations (meningitis, mumps, whooping cough, etc) for students to attend. I think most college students would trade the very very small risks of a vaccine for a “real” college experience. I know that my students are getting vaccinated as fast as they can, particularly the spring sports players. The Cooperstown website does acknowledge that no vaccines are currently  available for kids 12-15, so their requirement for this age doesn’t apply yet.

@Fan2024 posted:

College already require lots of extra vaccinations (meningitis, mumps, whooping cough, etc) for students to attend. I think most college students would trade the very very small risks of a vaccine for a “real” college experience. I know that my students are getting vaccinated as fast as they can, particularly the spring sports players. The Cooperstown website does acknowledge that no vaccines are currently  available for kids 12-15, so their requirement for this age doesn’t apply yet.

Again, none of those are required.  You always have the option to get an exemption, and it just requires a form from the state that you have a notary sign. I think a lot of students would like to have the choice as to whether or not to put an unapproved vaccine in their body.  Having a normal college experience isn't an either or in regards to getting a vaccine.

Last edited by baseballhs
@ARCEKU21 posted:

It’s going to be a hot topic in youth sports. Cooperstown said they are requiring all players to be vaccinated to participate this year. As you can imagine many teams are pulling out and lots of complaints.

The problem is cooperstown is a tournament for 12U teams, as of this time there is not a vaccine available for 12 year olds.  Our home town team pulled out because thats alot of money to risk for something that may not be available for you....

@SoCal OG posted:

... as it stands now, elementary schools in all 50 states and DC already require vaccinations for diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis; polio; measles and rubella (49 states and DC also require mumps vaccination); and the varicella (chickenpox) vaccination.  So there is already a precedent for requiring vaccinations...

Huh... sounds like we, as a country, have done some pretty good things with these types of serious illnesses, pandemics, diseases, etc.  Hard to imagine the countless deaths and debilitating illnesses that have been spared since some of these have been put in place.  Add to that the heavy restriction and warnings about smoking which have saved many more millions of lives.  (I only wish, for my parents and grandparents sake, the smoking part would have happened sooner.)

There have certainly been mis-steps and I will often be quick to point out what I believe to be over-steps along the way.  But, historically, government actions in times of significant medical and safety emergencies/catastrophes has often been very effective and beneficial overall.

 

@baseballhs posted:

All of the Covid vaccines, that are approved for emergency use.  There hasn't even been time to look at possible long term side effects.  I am perfectly fine with anyone who wants to have one, getting it, not at all ok with being told I have to.

While we dont have a long history with these specific vaccines (Moderna & Pfizer), we do have decades of research on mRNA.  This research has already shown mRNA poses almost no long term effects.  This is good enough for me.

By the way I'm not trying to persuade you or change your mind.  I'm comfortable with the available information and believe the risks (extremely slim) outweigh the negatives.  

I haven't found decades of positive result studies with mRNA...you might have sources you can share.  Articles from 2017 show that Moderna was failing with mRNA and was close to abandoning it.  Another journal article from March of 2019 stated that "Although mRNA vaccine technology has still not extensively tested in humans, publications of preclinical and early clinical tests have emerged in recent years, in which promising results were reported."Front. Immunol., 27 March 2019.

Again, there are people who are going to be comfortable with the amount of testing or believe the potential benefit outweighs the risk. That is fine.  It is also not unreasonable at all to feel that more testing needs to be done and mandating a vaccine that hasn't been tested in the same way that others have is a big issue. I trust my immune system at this point.

Last edited by baseballhs
@cabbagedad posted:

Huh... sounds like we, as a country, have done some pretty good things with these types of serious illnesses, pandemics, diseases, etc.  Hard to imagine the countless deaths and debilitating illnesses that have been spared since some of these have been put in place.  Add to that the heavy restriction and warnings about smoking which have saved many more millions of lives.  (I only wish, for my parents and grandparents sake, the smoking part would have happened sooner.)

There have certainly been mis-steps and I will often be quick to point out what I believe to be over-steps along the way.  But, historically, government actions in times of significant medical and safety emergencies/catastrophes has often been very effective and beneficial overall.



Covid should have been ... Here are the risks. Here’s how you avoid the risks. Now be an adult.

@RJM posted:

Covid should have been ... Here are the risks. Here’s how you avoid the risks. Now be an adult.

Man, RJM, I REALLY wish a larger majority of adults knew HOW to be adults and we could take that path with most of today's issues.  Unfortunately, decades of repeated behavior of far too many have proven otherwise and forced the need for more and more rules, laws, law enforcement, regulations...

Drugs, crime, abuse, cheating, polluting, driving recklessly, serving spoiled food, neglecting own children, infringing on rights of others, excessive drinking, cheating the government, corporate cheating, extreme unhealthy lifestyles, etc.

And, yeah, I'd love to buy into the conservative thought that we could take things into our own hands with these problems.  But again, far too many of those same people doing the same $h!tty stuff above would also be taking things into their own hands.   

I do believe it all starts at home.  But, hell, the government even has to show 1/3 of society how to be decent parents and spouses.  And probably another 1/3 need help but won't get it or take it.

No easy answers out there.

Last edited by cabbagedad

I was curious about when Pfizer, Moderna, and J&J could get actual approval and not just Emergency Use Authorization.  Apparently you can get EUA with 2 months of data after the second shot, but full approval after 6 months; they also check manufacturing for 4 months.  In other words, Pfizer and Moderna are ready to request full approval, which the data supports, very soon.

https://www.wusa9.com/article/...00-8468-194a6e0a21a4

Last edited by anotherparent
@cabbagedad posted:

Man, RJM, I REALLY wish a larger majority of adults knew HOW to be adults and we could take that path with most of today's issues.  Unfortunately, decades of repeated behavior of far too many have proven otherwise and forced the need for more and more rules, laws, law enforcement, regulations...

Drugs, crime, abuse, cheating, polluting, driving recklessly, serving spoiled food, neglecting own children, infringing on rights of others, excessive drinking, cheating the government, corporate cheating, extreme unhealthy lifestyles, etc.

And, yeah, I'd love to buy into the conservative thought that we could take things into our own hands with these problems.  But again, far too many of those same people doing the same $h!tty stuff above would also be taking things into their own hands.   

I do believe it all starts at home.  But, hell, the government even has to show 1/3 of society how to be decent parents and spouses.  And probably another 1/3 need help but won't get it or take it.

No easy answers out there.

So the dumb ones don’t make it. It’s the culling of the herd.

https://fb.watch/50w7xsPv89/

Last edited by RJM

@baseballHS,

sorry for slow reply - busy at work today. I did some poking around, and it doesn't seem like every college allows those vaccine waivers you mention. I checked Penn State and U Penn -- Penn State (public) does allow any student to choose to waive vaccines, but U Penn (private) only allows medical and religious waivers, not the more generic waiver you describe. I'm guessing that these rules vary by state, and also by education level (K-12 vs Higher Education). My native state of CA only allows medical waivers for K-12 vaccines. Bottom line --  young folks with strong feelings about vaccines would need to check the policies of the specific colleges they are considering.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×