W&L is usually very competitive in the ODAC. Top notch education that will cost you top notch dollars. Great facility...certainly one that many D1 schools would like to have. Very "preppie" in atmosphere and usually shows up in the rankings of top party schools.
VWC is perennially a top D3 team in our region. Very near the beach so weather is rarely an issue. I do not know much about academics there, but the coach is very well-respected. In my one visit there following my son's team, I was disappointed in the bland facilities. VWC won the D3 hoops title a couple years back.
Guilford is the Quaker-founded school in a nice section of Greensboro. Baseball has been down the past couple of years as they have struggled since the coaching change. Facility is so-so with a short porch...and wind generally blowing out. Very nice compact campus. Outstanding in basketball the past couple of years.
Of course, if you are looking at an ODAC school that offers the best of both worlds (outside of the hoops program), I could think of no better place than Lynchburg College