Skip to main content

hi

i just wanted to get your opinion on these swings.
the first swing is a live game: high fast ball.
the second swing is a BP: low and inside.

both lack prelaunch because i ommitted it at that time to gain clarity.

thanks to nikkio for helping me out with the web space.

thanks ahead for your answers.

first clip

http://webpages.charter.net/nickkio/Oswaldo_4.mpg

second clip

http://webpages.charter.net/nickkio/Oswaldo_1.mpg



IN CASE of failure to display, you can check them out at Batspeed.com, thread "two swings by Toti" posted by Nickkio


toti. Wink
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

toti,

I replied on another site but I will add something. you swing is better than average having all the absolutes. Watching the hip/ shoulder separartion I would say that the most power improvement would come from increasing the hips turn ahead of the shoulder turn . They seem to be moving together through launch. Look at Youthbaseabllcoaching site at Gonzalez at his separation
C-ocking the hips going into toe touch allows you to un-c-ock them harder and increase the x factor stretch. ( see Toms post) . I am sure you would have great power with a focus point being hips rotation ahead of shoulder rotation. Good swing . I would take it any day.

With a base hit in follow through there would be what a no call by hitting the catcher? I don't know?
Last edited {1}
thanks everybody for the swift responses. i really appreciate this site for the quality of the discussions and the people.


Swingbuster:

i defenetly agree with you that i need more separation. i have worked on that lately and have ripped tremendous results. when i hit with the hips it is tremendous bat speed and it feels like the bat has a live of his own. i have to hang on to it because it gets wild. however i dont know if need more pop being a contact hitter. in the live game clip i posted i got a line drive hit that just bounced off the dirt behind second base. the ball was hit hard and square, no chance for the short stop to catch it. that´s all i need. i dont know. i am never going to be a doubles hitter, eventhough i am currently lifting weights. i rather hit for average.
with this swing, i am able to hit the ball hard, even when i am late on the ball. i seem to hit it in the meat most of the time. i really dont know.


bbscout:

your post made me think if I should go back to this swing and forget about too much hip rotation and adding more pop. right now my swing has more hip and the ball is hit harder, however i have lost a little control on the bat head, which right now seems to have a life of its own. and right now it is becoming increasingly difficult to hit the high heat. without the hip movement, i could hit the high better. now it is different because i stride with a bent front knee or "sit to hit" which makes it harder to adjust to high pitches, though it produces much more bat speed and more pop. what do you think?



about the catcher, i drilled him 3 times in that game and got a warning from the umpire. i think it was my fault. i rotated the upper body in the follow through too much and ended up almost spinning back. i stood way back in the box because i was hitting fast balls only. i went 2 for 4 with a walk. fun game. i remember discussing the "swing level" guys before the game and how i should change my swing and not "tilt" or get "under".

thanks everybody

toti.
Hi toti, I feel that your hip rotation in the game swing was fine, and also the shoulder rotation was good too. The only thing you did wrong was let go of the bat at the end of your follow through, and that is why you drilled the catcher. Hang on to the bat with both hands and you won't kill the catcher, and it won't change your swing either. IMO, you are a line drive type hitter and you showed a good line drive type swing. How tall are you and how much do you weigh?
toti-

really nice Job!

One reason I dislike the top hand release cue is you end up throwing the bat at the catcher a lot.With a good swing,you can keep both hands on and not lose anything.(Not that you use that cue,necessarily).

I would say you can get slightly more coil/uncoil by trying a few things.

The clip is a little blurry,but it looks to me like the top hand comes away from the shoulder slightly early.This will not happen if you keep the back scap loading as you drop and tilt.See if this accentuates the feel of coil/uncoil/reversal.

Also looks like you are alittle upright/could bend more at waist when yousit to hit.This is a high pitch and maybe you anticipated that or recognized it earlybut in general you want to start out with enough bend to get the low one because it's easier to come up if its higher than get down more later.The added flex in the waist can also transfer momentum better when you commit the backside and go "up" which you do well.

One more generic comment.Donny mentioned hip cok/uncok.Tis is a complex andpoorly described area for the most part.You do it well,so I would be interested in your perception of what you do.My thinking is as follows.

You cok the hip early with the inward turn.Bat tilts up a little,front knee turns in,hip inches/bends/flexes at waist/front hip elevates.As the swing proceeds,the hip turns back slightly with the scap load then "counterrotation" starts and the hip rotates open some by front toe touch lead by the front leg turning open(externally rotating)but hands are stil back and hip is still coked insense of elevated front hip and pinch in waist(front leg didn't reach out along with loss of pinch/elevation-good!).

Now when you "drop and tilt" heel drop will trigger/accelerate the rotating/opening of the hips as the elevation of the front hip drops.You don't want the hips stopping your coil and pulling you off the ball,so you resist the torso opening by keeping the back scap loaded and tilting the shoulders so you feel the front side "firmup"/stretch up to the front shoulder/feel of last quick bit of coil(xfactor stretch),then you are ready to Pull with the bottom handas in Gwynn's description of Bonds swing.This pull then triggers the arch/commiting of the back hip which directs the momentum you are transferring as you uncoil "UP".If you get/retain a little more flex/cok in the hip,you may get more energy turning the bat when you pull/commit the back hip.Let me know if any of this feels right.
hi


thanks for the insights.


that swing is an early Epstein swing, that´s why you see some disconnection. i am in the process of incorporating more leg and scapula load. i have erased the wrapping of the bat to third base you see here and the bat is more centered, plus i lean forward more and bend front knee. then i rotate the heel of front foot and lean back. i haven´t tried this in a real game so far, only with wiffles now. i hope it works better.

bbscout:
i am 1.73 meters tall, 74 kg. i am lean and mean Cool. however i am in the middle of a weight lifting program and protein shakes that is adding a lot of muscle mass. do you really think i am a line drive gap hitter? i just look at myself as contact. i have hit some doubles but....it is hard not let the bat go on the left hand. you cant imagine the rotational momentum that´s generated here. it is hard for me to get a good grip and not let the bat fly. i am moving some serious heavy wood here and i am very skinny.

Tom,

you have given some smart comments. to tell you the truth, i was not awared of the hip **** thing when i took this swing. i didn´t know it was important. you can see this is a very linear stride. i dont hip ****. and i have no clue of how i am going to incorporate it in my swing. i have tried it and it disrupts connection big time. i dont now.

i dont quite follow you in the explanation about how to coil and uncoil. i am gessing here but i am not sure. can you break it down in a much simpler way? anyway, i will try to coil and uncoil together with scap load and unload with the wiffles as soon as i recover from my knee injury. i am just lifting now, no baseball for me at the moment.

you are right about your comment about sit to hit. at that time, i didn´t know this concept. it is hard for me to adjust to high fast balls though.

thanks

toti
toti,

If I may - after reading your posts a few times I was very impressed with your description of your swing mechanics. Rarely have I seen a youngster describe his own swing - and adjustments to his swing - with such understanding and clarity.

Do you find that many young players in Spain (or other European countries) have a similar level of swing mechanics knowledge?

Thanks - and again - very impressive for a young player.
Posted by toti
Member posted January 22, 2004 02:06 PM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Excerpted:

"hi swingbuster

way to go swing buster. and while you are at it, tell them to swing with their hands only and not use the legs and see how far the ball travels off the tea.

for the record, i have nothing against pros. i have something against pros that want to teach balloney and they know they cant. i am against a pro, taking his credibility, to go and spread ill advice among clueless amateurs like he was giving candy. giving advice with no basis except your biased mental feel and perceptions.

toti"

Sorry for getting off subject here - but I'm curious - do you feel that most young ballplayers in Spain share this perspective? Thanks.
Posted by toti
Member posted January 22, 2004 08:02 AM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Excerpted:

"hi jemaz

sorry for being rude before. it has been years of taking this bull in the field that irritate me.

on the other hand, i would never ever pay attention to a "natural" giving advice. they dont have a clue as to what they do with their body, let alone being able to teach anything-most are retards with no education-.

truth is they can not verbalize let alone teach what they do. then just two minutes later, they swing at a low pitch with a tilt in their shoulder and you go "what in the world is this "level" swing?.

in fact, i would not listen to a hall of famer with much attention. they can do ill to you. i would rather "watch" what they do and not "what they say".

have a nice day

toti "
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posts: 7 | From: spain | Registered: January 20, 2004


Toti,

Sorry again for being such an obsessive pain in the butt - but do you feel most young players in Spain also share these sentiments?

Thanks. Wink

Last edited {1}

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×