quote:
Originally posted by 1943 yankees:
Mr. Taylor,
Don't understand why you would correct your post, you made it appear you were there for the play, and you obviously were not. Correcting it does not change that, perhaps you should have just began with, "someone told me".
The fans down at our end could not see the umpire at home, so there was tremendous confusion. You are absolutely right, the umpires should have had a conversation.
When there are three umpires, which ump makes the call on the catch? The ump at third called Harrington out at third. He obviously thought there was a catch, or did the ump at first call Kilmon out on the catch? Maybe, the VP will find out and report it on Monday!
Wow...
.I did see the play, but it was from the left field corner. Why the attempt to discredit? Someone asked a question about the game and I attempted as honestly as I could to answer their question. Your response was posted 1 minute before mine and if I had seen it, I would not have bothered.
As for the rest of the above post, I'm not sure why you are addressing me there. I made no mention of any controversial umpire calls. From my vantage point, I saw that there was some upset players on the field following the play, but had no idea what their issues were. After over 12 hours at Landstown yesterday, I WAS on my way to the parking lot after the final out was made.