I'll jump in here on the EC Astros question since I have a pretty good point of reference to draw from.
For former Coach Gut's benefit
, let me state my qualifications that allow me to provide a little insight in responding to the question:
- I played for Guerry Baldwin back in the day. Guerry runs East Cobb Baseball and is the Head Coach for the East Cobb Astros 16U club.
- I coached for Guerry in the East Cobb program prior to moving to Keller 5 years ago and both my sons played East Cobb baseball. We moved to Texas before either of the boys turned 16 so neither of them got to the point where they could tryout for the Astros.
- The East Cobb program is nationally recognized and was named the Amatuer Program of the Decade for the 90s by
Baseball America winning a bunch of national titles along the way. Guerry's Astros squad year end and year out has been recognized as one of the top flite 16U squads in the country.
Having said all that, I know a little about the program and how Guerry runs things. As you'd imagine it's incredibly competitive and considered a big time honor for a player to make the Astros club. Think of it this way, if you took the best of the best from the Mustangs, DBAT, Tigers, Marshalls, Blackhawks, Panthers, etc. and formed one team that's what you have with East Cobb Astros. Quite simply, you have to be a 16 year-old stud to play for him. Also, I don't recall the specific numbers but in tracking the players who played for Guerry and the Astros through the end of the program (when they turn 18), 98-99% eventually went D1 or got drafted. Again, I've been a few years removed from it but I'd imagine the numbers are still tracking the same.
Guerry is strictly in it for the players and his program,
not the parents. He makes that very clear. Quite honestly, during my time in the program, I found very few parents who really liked Guerry. Want to know how much he cared what the parents thought? Not one bit. Having a parent upset with him doesn't faze him a single iota because if a family decides to pack it in and leave during the summer he simply reaches back and brings another 16 year old stud into the fold. I've seen it happen a few times.
Don't get me wrong, the parents very much respect his coaching ability (he's one of the best and the guys who are his assistant coaches are also top notch) and the program's track record speaks for itself but Guerry's not in it to be their friend. Also, he makes it very clear at the start of the summer what his expectations are for the team, playing time to be expected for
each player, etc. I've sat in on one of his player/parent kickoff meetings and there is no fuzz on his message. He runs his squad like a college program. Generally speaking pitchers are pitchers only regardless if they are a stud position player with their school team.
It doesn't surprise me at all that parents are grumbling but, honestly, they went into the deal eyes wide open.
So, to answer your question DTiger, if we were still living in Georgia and either one of my boys would have had the chance to play for Guerry Baldwin and the Astros then yes we would have opted for doing that fully knowing what we were getting into. His program's track record speaks for itself and it would be an indicator, not a guarantee, that my kids may have a future playing the game beyond HS. Plus, the coaching my guys would have gotten would have been the best in the area and one of the tops in the country.
Sorry to be so long winded but I thought a former East Cobb perspective may be somewhat interesting. Back to the salt mines ...