quote:
Originally posted by BlueDog:
In a high level swing, the brain tells the body when to swing.....This happens before front foot plant....The intent to swing forces the front foot to the ground....
I don't believe this is accurate. The placeing of the foot to the ground has nothing to do with the "when to swing" signal.
My best evidence is how hitters adjust to off speed pitches. When the toe is down and they detect off speed, they shift momentum, sit, lower, hold the load and then drop the heel and swing. So, the placing of the toe on the ground is really not related to the swing decision.
I will agree that the best hitters have very little time from toe touch to heel drop...or from toe touch to swing launch.
But, I think your analysis is slightly flawed. And for this reason, I think the drill can be effective assuming the ultimate goal is to "get the d a m n foot down on time".
The "offspeed adjustment technique", that high level hitters use, can be used by low level hitters with high hitter goals, to learn to hit fast pitching.
After all, no-stride hitters have the foot down plenty early.