Somewhat (no, very) off original post, but question remains for me regarding PG All-Tournament designations for players at WWBA. When the Patrick Ebert tweet hit my phone that 18U WWBA All-Tournament selections were now posted, I eagerly went to the PG site to see how local kids we know had done.
I was dismayed to see that PG seems to have cheapened the designation of All-Tournament by seemingly lowering the batting standards to a floor of .200 battng average. I can understand Cooperstown Dreams Park inducting every kid into its hall of fame and presenting rings. But a PG All-Tournament designation is supposed to mean something and for the life of me I can't justify a .200 batting average as worthy of such status being awarded.
I do not fault the kids who didn't hit better. That's baseball. I will question the validity of any award or recognition to vast numbers of players whose performance was substantiallly below the threshold of what is commonly considered deserving of any kind of All Tournament status. Players who batted in a majority of their pool games, were consistent at the plate and hit well are at the top of the list of honorees. But the recognition of their accomplishment is diminished when the standards are set so low. A .667 hitter is All-Tournament, as is a .201 hitter. That just doesn't make sense. Perhaps PG should institute an Honorable Mention All-Tournament if it wants to include more players to enhance their experience at this major tournament.
Pitchers have to pitch a minimum of 3 innings, it appears, to qualify for PG's recognition and there seemingly is a standard of excellence required which is consistent with prevailing standards for pitching excellence.
PG is the most highly-respected scouting and ranking service of youth players. However, the 18U WWBA All-Tournament selections predicated on batting average seem to be more of a 'juice-box baseball" approach than a realistic recognition of excellence.
We've just returned from the 17U WWBA. As always, the tournament was superbly run, the LakePoint facilities are second to none and the experience was memorable for us and NTGson. The boy batted well, pitched OK with an ERA of .000 but didn't have enough innings(only 2), I assume, to qualify for All-Tournament as a pitcher.
Thank you PG for creating an environment which fosters an expectation of excellence.