Skip to main content

I was just made aware of a "quirk" regarding the Transfer Portal and thought I would share for whatever it's worth.

An athlete transferring from a multi-divisional athletic program will be shown in the Transfer Portal as a transfer from the level for which the overall athletic program is known.

Example:  With Dallas Baptist being a D2 program in all sports other than baseball, a baseball player from DBU who enters the Transfer Portal will be listed as transferring from a D2 baseball program!  I've been made aware that a few players transferring from DBU are apparently only receiving inquiries from D2 and D3 programs because they appear in the Portal as currently being with a D2 program.

For any of you with other kids or friends in other sports at multi-divisional programs, you may want to make them aware of this.  (Such as D2 or D3 programs that sponsor hockey at the D1 level.)

I've inquired about this and have been told that the school can't do anything to change the way that such an athlete's profile will appear in the Transfer Portal.  It apparently has to do with the way that Portal was "constructed" when the NCAA set it up.  Coaches at other D1 programs can still look up and find the players who are transferring from DBU, but they would need to look for players leaving a D2 program to find the DBU guys listed in the Portal.

Last edited by Rick at Informed Athlete
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well, this is interesting. Dallas Baptist is a D1 baseball program who just won 34 games this season.  Beat a bunch of ranked teams along the way. From 2014 to 2019, they won AT LEAST 40 games each season. Admittedly, I don't know much of anything about them (just looked all this up), but clearly they're no bottom feeder D1 program. Far from it, in fact. So the question is why? Why are portal kids from there only getting inquiries from D2 and D3 programs? Is it because times are really tough and there is so much talent at all levels right now that going from D1 Dallas Baptist to D2 or D3 is simply a product of the current environment? Because what's the alternative? That D1 coaches aren't actually aware that Dallas Baptist is a D1?  Times being tough just sucks, but everyone is dealing with it right now. But D1 coaches that aren't aware and educated enough to know of Dallas Baptist? Can that really be a possibility? If so, that is super scary. In my mind, this "quirk" should be a total non-issue for any D1 coach with a brain, right?

My thought with DBU is that D1 coaches are only looking at other D1 players in the portal..so if DBU players are listed as D2 they could very well not even be seen by other D1 coaches...it would not seem odd to any D1 coach that there are no DBU players in the portal...I am guessing the portal can be filtered by division for the coaches looking...

I think that Rick did a super job of explaining about the "quirk".

Thank you Rick!

I am sure that, coaches from the Midwest that are familiar with the Missouri Valley Conference know that DBU is in a D2 that plays in a D1 conference. I wouldn't necessarily think that those from other regions might be familiar and I will assume a few folks here wouldn't know that either.

Last edited by TPM
@TPM posted:
I am sure that, coaches from the Midwest that are familiar with the Missouri Valley Conference know that DBU is in a D2 that plays in a D1 conference. I wouldn't necessarily think that those from other regions might be familiar and I will assume a few folks here wouldn't know that either.

Granted, I am a nobody and there may be people here that aren't familiar with DBU like myself, but check this out. Number 5 in wins over the last 7 years? I think it's fair to question how knowledgeable some of these D1 coaches are. So maybe a coach filtered D2 out of their spreadsheet. But I'd think any D1 coach worth his salt would find it conspicuously odd that DBU players are never on their spreadsheet.  We all know how small the college baseball coaching world is, right?  Everyone talks to everyone.  So I really struggle understanding how a coach could miss on DBU due to spreadsheet filtering.

TOP 10 PROGRAMS BY WINS SINCE 2015
1. Florida (293)
2. Louisville (287)
3. Vanderbilt (286)
4. LSU (279)
5. DBU (270)
6. TCU (269)
6. Texas Tech (269)
8. Arkansas (266)
9. Oregon State (263)
9. Southern Miss (263)
9. Texas A&M (263)

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×