Skip to main content

quote:
Originally posted by wayback:
Extension is done at the proper time during rotation to untuck the rear arm and allow the top hand to rotate and whip the barrel into and through contact.


I think that extension happens automatically as the result of the powerful swing (and after the point of contact).

IOW, extension is a non-teach.

If you generate enough batspeed, then your arms, hands, and wrists aren't strong enough to generate enough centripetal force to counteract the centrifugal force that is generated by the bat. The arms then get pulled into the Power V.

The back elbow and hands are connected at the point of contact...






...and then get pulled into the Power V...



Last edited by thepainguy
Lets take that last picture.

  • Hands have just come off of the "Merry-Go-Round" and you can see that they have not extended straight, have not rolled over anything...
  • Look at that frontside. His toe is still maintaining instead of flying out or getting on the heel (toe up).
  • Notice that the body is still maintaining tilt.
  • Notice that back toe. No squishing the toe here.
  • Hips and shoulders are just about parallel to each other.
  • Notice in the crowd that CoachB25 is jumping for joy. Ok so I lied about that one but I wish I was there.


I love those pics. Of course a million others might not see what I see but then again, that's part of the fun of this. JMHO!
quote:
Hands have just come off of the "Merry-Go-Round" and you can see that they have not extended straight, have not rolled over anything


Pujols doesn't form the Power V or roll his wrists until a couple of frames AFTER the point of contact.


quote:
Notice that back toe. No squishing the toe here.


He does FINISH in a position that looks like squishing the bug, but that's well after the Point Of Contact.





I think that people looked at photos like the ones above and (mistakenly) assumed that that that was what good hitters also looked like DURING their swings. Of course, people who do that fail to notice that Pujols' toe is actually OFF THE GROUND at the point of contact.



quote:
Notice in the crowd that CoachB25 is jumping for joy. Ok so I lied about that one but I wish I was there.


I was rolling around on the floor screaming "He did it! He did it! He did it!"
Last edited by thepainguy
quote:
Originally posted by BlueDog:
quote:
It appears that Bluedog has now gone over to the DARK SIDE!!! LOL!


Coach, I've always taught to let the arms and hands find the swing plane.........

The difference between me and the DARK SIDE is that I teach only one engine and it isn't the hands and arms.... Smile


Bluedog, you can't fault a guy for making a post every once in a while just for fun can you?
While I agree on the finish not being as important, it does some significant information in my opinion. I agree that matching the swing plane will affect whether the finish is high or low and so, it isn't representative of commenting on one fixted type of swing ie. finish high. However, it tells a story of balance, tilt, and efficient rotation. Bluedog and I have disagreed to this in degrees and I do agree with him that the ball has left the bat and so... In video, I can sometimes show a hitter that finish and they can tell me what they percieve that they did wrong in the swing. I believe that it can be effective in helping hitters understand the swing process to a limited but beneficial degree.

SORRY, I WAS INTERRUPTED AND POSTED THIS WITHOUT AN EXAMPLE:

This past week at our hitting camp, a parent was upset over their childs "finish." This young man was coming off of that back foot, and at times placing his foot down on the plate. I asked the parent why was this bad. I received a couple of answers but lack of balance was the main focus. I then asked that same parent was their child balanced during the swing process and how much energy did that parent want stored in that body after uncoil? In this example, this young man was hitting the heck out of the ball and so, what appeared to be a bad finish, I hope was used to explain to a parent the realities of a young man really getting after it hitting.
Last edited by CoachB25
It's like holding up on a throw to home by a pitcher.
You could pull something??
As far as finish of the follow thru??
If, That's the word.

IF you hit the Ball, and you follow thru!!
That's when you let go of the bat and Run like a crazed pack of Dog's to first base.

Were you finish would be determind by were the ball was pitched?
EH
BlueDog
quote:
So, what does someone who believes it matters look for in a follow-through?......A high finish?...Medium?.....Low?........All?.......None?........


Meaning were you finish your follow-thru?

Low outside pitch=Low outside follow-thru

High inside pitch=High inside follow-thru

Do you catch the pattern going on here?

Do they call that making adjustment's to the pitch that's being thrown??
EH
quote:
I teach, and always have, to find the swing plane with the hands and arms


Bluedog, Merry Christmas to you and yours...

Agreed, and in finding the swing plane with hands/arms your posture should adjust accordingly without any conscious action similar to that of the rear elbow.

This kid had a very nice year at the plate and believe this is what they had in mind when they said "short to the ball, long through the ball" These video's would also seem to disprove the hands along for the ride theory.



Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×